The Ultimate Guide to Buying Paint from a Hardware Store Near Me

So, you’re ready to paint. Maybe your walls need a refresh, or you’re finally tackling that DIY furniture makeover. Either way, picking the right paint, finish, and tools is key to getting pro-level results. But with so many options, where do you even start?

No worries because Wally's Hardware got you. Here’s everything you need to know before heading to a hardware store near me or you to grab your supplies.

Step 1: Choose the Right Type of Paint 

First things first: what are you painting? Not all paint is the same, and picking the wrong one can lead to peeling, chipping, or a finish that just doesn’t look right.

Interior Paint – Best for walls, ceilings, and indoor surfaces. Comes in latex (water-based) and oil-based.

Exterior Paint – Designed to withstand rain, heat, and humidity. Perfect for outdoor walls, gates, and fences.

Wood & Furniture Paint – Use enamel or chalk paint for a smooth, durable finish.

Metal Paint – If you're painting metal surfaces like gates or grills, go for anti-rust enamel.

Concrete Paint – Best for floors, patios, or rough walls that need a durable coat.

Step 2: Pick the Right Finish

Now that you know what type of paint you need, let’s talk about finishes. The right finish makes a huge difference in how your space looks and how easy it is to maintain.

Flat / Matte – No shine, hides imperfections. Best for ceilings and low-traffic walls.
Eggshell – Slightly washable, soft finish. Good for bedrooms and living rooms.
Satin – Easy to clean, slight sheen. Ideal for kitchens and bathrooms.
Semi-Gloss – Shiny, highly washable. Perfect for doors, trims, and high-moisture areas.
Glossy / High-Gloss – Super reflective and durable. Great for cabinets and furniture.

Pro Tip: If you have kids or pets, go for satin or semi-gloss because they’re easy to clean!

Step 3: Pick the Right Paint Color

This is where things get fun. But let’s be honest. Choosing a color can be overwhelming. Here’s how to make it easier:

Consider the Lighting – Natural light makes colors look lighter, while artificial lighting can add warm or cool tones.
Stick to a Palette – If you’re unsure, go for neutral shades (whites, beiges, or grays) and add pops of color with furniture or décor.
Use a Sample – Always test a small patch on your wall before committing to a color.
Know the Mood – Soft blues and greens = calming. Bold reds and yellows = energetic.

Pro Tip: Classic colors like off-white, light gray, or warm beige work with almost any interior style.

Step 4: Get the Right Painting Tools

A great paint job isn’t just about the paint. It’s also about the tools.

Brushes – Best for edges, corners, and small details. Choose a high-quality brush to avoid streaks.
Rollers – Ideal for large walls and ceilings. Use a short-nap roller for smooth surfaces and a long-nap roller for textured walls.
Painter’s Tape – Keeps edges clean and prevents smudging.
Drop Cloths – Protects your floors and furniture from drips.
Sandpaper & Primer – Helps paint stick better and last longer.

Pro Tip: If you want a super smooth finish, don’t skip the primer. It helps even out surfaces and makes colors pop.